The Court of First Instance and Order of Talavera de la Reina completely dismissed the lawsuit brought against Talavera de la Reina. Apollonio Manzano PP spokesperson of La Nava de Ricomarillo city council accused of violation of honor rights … The city secretary computer figure has now been proven to never have existed. The resolution would completely exonerate the popular lawmaker and order the plaintiffs to pay their costs.
The judgment, dated October 29, 2025, concludes that the popular MP’s questioning expressions were made in the context of a political debate or the exercise of control by opposition members and do not constitute any insult, attack or personal attack, but rather constitute criticism protected by freedom of expression. Similarly, the judges emphasized that these statements had a sufficient factual basis, were proportionate and referred to conduct of public relevance.
with full justice
In a statement, the City of Toledo PP said it was very positive that the judge found that the popular spokesperson acted with full legitimacy within the scope of his duties in defending the interests of his neighbors and calling for transparency in the administration of city government, and that it regretted that this situation had arisen, forcing him to legalize what should have been a normal political discussion within the City Council.
What is particularly worrying is that instead of fostering dialogue and accountability, the secretary and the mayor chose a path that was ultimately roundly rejected by the courts. The judiciary acknowledged that none of the popular spokesperson’s expressions threatened the secretary’s reputation, and also recalled that, as a public servant and a position that directly influences the life of the municipality, the secretary is subject to scrutiny and criticism.
In the case of demonstrations related to the mayor, the judgment makes clear that the expressions did not refer to the mayor personally, but to specific actions, which took place within legitimate political control.
Although the ruling has not yet been finalized, it can be appealed, making it clear that its enforcement will only mean that an appeal will prolong attempts to curb the opposition’s activities.
Judicial setbacks against PSOE
For all these reasons, the PP of Toledo conveyed to the popular spokesperson recognition for his serious, responsible and courageous work, always focused on defending the rights of the residents of La Nava de Ricomarillo. Despite facing pressure and unsubstantiated accusations, it has maintained an impeccable performance with a focus on holding local governments to account for decisions that directly impact local residents.
The secretary intervener himself admitted in court. Must be a member of the PSOE Executive. This situation has become completely public, and Apolonio Manzano has expressed concern about the need to guarantee impartiality in the management of the municipality, which is part of the due administrative duties exercised by any opposition party. However, in no case is it aimed at discrediting the person, but rather, as the judgment made clear, pointing out a situation that, in the opinion of the PP, should be revealed with full transparency.
Similarly, the provincial PP has expressed hope that it will be abandoned by the city council after this judicial ruling. La Nava de Ricomarillo This power relationship makes it difficult for companies to function normally and makes it difficult for the legitimate activities of the opposition, which is the basis of democracy, to be respected.
About The Author
